ORDER A WHIT'S FROZEN PIE

Home/Store/ORDER A WHIT'S FROZEN PIE

Whit's Frozen Custard Pies

Choose from our selection of popular pie flavors or create your own masterpiece. We offer a 9” graham cracker pie crust in regular or chocolate, filled with your choice of our chocolate, vanilla or our flavor of the week. Then, personalize it with your favorite toppings.

Our pies serve approximately 6 people and should be kept frozen until ready to serve. Each pie is crafted individually and may differ from photos shown.

Please note, all pie orders require at least 24 hours notice. You can select the best date and time for pick-up at least 48 hours from the time of your order. Need something sooner? Stop by or give us a call to see what's available in our freezer.

Discount codes do not apply to pie orders*

Strawberry Pie
Strawberry Pie
Strawberry Pie
Build Your Own Custom Pie
Build Your Own Custom Pie
Build Your Own Custom Pie
Celebration Pie
Celebration Pie
Celebration Pie
Dirty Worm Pie
Dirty Worm Pie
Dirty Worm Pie
Cookies 'n Creme Pie
Cookies 'n Creme Pie
Cookies 'n Creme Pie
Cookie Monster Pie
Cookie Monster Pie
Cookie Monster Pie
Chocoholic Pie
Chocoholic Pie
Chocoholic Pie
Peanut Butter Buckeye Pie
Peanut Butter Buckeye Pie
Peanut Butter Buckeye Pie
Display prices in:USD
Skip to main content
Whit's Pataskala Online Ordering
Menu
Home
Frozen Cakes
Frozen Pies
Ice Cream Social Packs
Ordering/Payment Info
Mobile Truck/Catering
Gift Cards