Specialty Sundaes & Whitsers

Home/Store/Specialty Sundaes & Whitsers

Pick your favorite from our most popular combinations, available as a sundae (toppings on top of your custard) or a whitser (toppings blended into your custard).

Broad Street Blitz
Broad Street Blitz
Broad Street Blitz
TOP SELLING ITEM!
Buckeye Madness
Buckeye Madness
Buckeye Madness
Caramel Apple
Caramel Apple
Caramel Apple
Cookie Monster
Cookie Monster
Cookie Monster
Cool Coffee
Cool Coffee
Cool Coffee
Grasshopper
Grasshopper
Grasshopper
Hawaiian Lu'Au
Hawaiian Lu'Au
Hawaiian Lu'Au
2024 Whitser Madness Winner
Buzzer Batter
Buzzer Batter
Buzzer Batter
NEW ITEM!
"The Elvis" Sundae or Whitser
"The Elvis" Sundae or Whitser
"The Elvis" Sundae or Whitser
Mud Pie
Mud Pie
Mud Pie
Pataskala Delight
Pataskala Delight
Pataskala Delight
O'Henry George
O'Henry George
O'Henry George
The Ohio Wonder
The Ohio Wonder
The Ohio Wonder
Customer Favorite!
Extreme Reese's
Extreme Reese's
Extreme Reese's
"The Elvis"
"The Elvis"
"The Elvis"
Display prices in:USD
Skip to main content
Whit's Pataskala Online Ordering
Menu
Home
Order Now
Flavor Calendar
Whit's Cakes & Pies
Party Packs
Ordering Info
Catering
Gift Cards
Mother's Day