Home/Store/Order a Whit's Frozen Cake or Pie/Whit's Cakes

Create your own Custom Cake

+6

+5

+4

+3

+2

Create your own Custom Cake

Product Details

Building Your Own Custom Cake is Easy!

Choose your size: small (serves 4-6) or large (serves 6-10)
Choose Your Custard Flavor: Chocolate, Vanilla, or 1/2 chocolate and 1/2 vanilla
Pick Your Center Filling: Select your favorite from our list
Add Your Toppings: Make it uniquely yours by choosing toppings that will be in the middle & top

All our cakes come with whipped cream topping! Most cakes also include a chocolate drizzle coating, except for fruit-based cakes.

$24.00

Cake Size:

Small Cake (4-6 people)

Large Cake (6-10 people) (+$10.00)

Custard Flavor:

Vanilla Custard

Chocolate Custard

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanille

Center Filling (1 is required):

Fudge (most popular)

Peanut Butter

Caramel

Strawberries

Bing Cherry Topping

Blueberry Topping

Raspberry

Triple Berry (raspberry, strawberry, blueberry) (+$2.00)

Toppings (used in the center & on top):

Almonds (+$1.50)

Apple Topping (+$1.50)

Banana Slices (+$1.50)

Bing Cherries (+$1.50)

Blueberry Topping (+$1.50)

Brownie Bites (+$1.50)

Butterfinger (+$1.50)

Candy Cane (seasonal) (+$1.50)

Cheesecake Bites (+$1.50)

Chocolate Flakes (+$1.50)

Chopped Nuts (+$1.50)

Cookies & Creme (+$1.50)

Cookie Dough Bites (+$1.50)

Crunch Coat (+$1.50)

Graham Crackers (+$1.50)

Gummy Worms (+$1.50)

Heath Bar (+$1.50)

Hot Caramel (+$1.50)

Hot Fudge (+$1.50)

Macadamia Nuts (+$1.50)

Marshmallow Topping (+$1.50)

M&M's (+$1.50)

Peanut Butter (+$1.50)

Pecans (+$1.50)

Pineapple Topping (+$1.50)

Raspberry Topping (+$1.50)

Reese's Cups (+$1.50)

Reese's Pieces (+$1.50)

Snickers (+$1.50)

Spanish Peanuts (+$1.50)

Sprinkles (+$1.50)

Strawberries (+$1.50)

Toasted Coconut (+$1.50)

Create your own Custom Cake

Display prices in:USD

Skip to main content

Whit's Pataskala Online Ordering

Flavor Calendar

Whit's Cakes & Pies