Home/Store/Valentine's Day

Create Your Own Valentine's Pie

+3

+2

Create Your Own Valentine's Pie

Product Details

Create Your Own Valentine's Pie!

Design your perfect custard pie creation by choosing your pie crust, custard flavor and all your favorite toppings! Keep it frozen until you're ready to serve.

Select the best date and time for pick-up, at least 24 hours from the time of your order. Need something sooner? Drop by or give us a call to see what's available in our freezer!

$13.00

Choose Your Crust:

Graham Cracker Crust

Chocolate Graham Cracker Crust (+$3.00)

Gluten Free Graham Cracker Crust (+$3.00)

Choose Your Custard Flavor:

Vanilla Custard

Chocolate Custard

Chocolate Covered Strawberry

Pick-Up Date:

Wednesday February 12

Thursday February 13

Friday February 14

Saturday February 15

Sunday February 16

Optional Candy/Misc Toppings:

Brownie Bites (+$1.50)

Butterfinger Candy (+$1.50)

Cheesecake Bites (+$1.50)

Chocolate Flakes (+$1.50)

Cookie Dough Bites (+$1.50)

Cookies 'n Creme (+$1.50)

Gummy Worms (+$1.50)

Heath Bar (+$1.50)

M&M's (+$1.50)

Reese's Cups (+$1.50)

Reese's Pieces (+$1.50)

Snickers (+$1.50)

Sprinkles (+$1.50)

Whipped Cream (+$1.50)

Optional Liquid Toppings:

Chocolate Syrup (+$1.50)

Hot Caramel (+$1.50)

Hot Fudge (+$1.50)

Marshmallow Topping (+$1.50)

Mint Topping (+$1.50)

Peanut Butter (+$1.50)

Sea Salt Caramel (+$1.50)

Optional Fruit Toppings:

Banana Slices (+$1.50)

Bing Cherries (+$1.50)

Blueberry Topping (+$1.50)

Pineapple Topping (+$1.50)

Raspberry Topping (+$1.50)

Strawberries (+$1.50)

Optional Nut Toppings:

Almonds (+$1.50)

Cashews (+$1.50)

Chopped Nuts (+$1.50)

Macadamia Nuts (+$1.50)

Pecans (+$1.50)

Spanish Peanuts (+$1.50)

Create Your Own Valentine's Pie

Display prices in:USD

Skip to main content

NOW ACCEPTING PRE-ORDERS FOR VALENTINE'S DAY CAKES, PIES & SWEETHEART PARTY PACKS!

Whit's Pataskala Online Ordering

Flavor Calendar

Valentine's Day

Whit's Cakes & Pies